What 70-Year-Old Couples Told Me About Staying Together. None of It Was Romantic.
I asked twelve couples who had been married more than forty years what kept them in it. The answers were almost boring. That was the point.
I started this project because my parents announced their separation in February, after forty-three years. I was thirty-six and I had assumed, the way children of long marriages do, that the math was settled. It was not settled. So I did what writers do when they are confused about their own lives. I made it someone else's problem. I asked twelve couples I knew, ranging in age from sixty-eight to eighty-four, all married more than forty years, the same question. What kept you in this. I expected stories about grand love. I got, instead, a lot of stories about kitchens.
Couple one, Edith and Marvin, married fifty-one years, retired teachers in Pittsburgh. Edith said, we agreed early on that whoever cooked did not also clean. She said this was the single most important agreement of their marriage. Marvin said, more important than the wedding vows. They were not joking. They said they had watched friends split over what they called uneven labor resentment, the slow burn of one person doing more invisible work, and they had short-circuited it with a rule about pots.
Couple two, Hannah and Yusuf, married forty-six years, both retired from a hospital in Boston. Their answer was that they had separate bathrooms. Hannah said, I love this man more than my own life, and I do not want to smell him in the morning. Yusuf nodded. He said this was non-negotiable starting in year nine. They had remodeled twice in two houses to preserve the rule. They said the cost was worth it twenty times over. I wrote this down twice.
Couple three, Marian and Peter, married fifty-eight years, farmers in upstate New York. Their answer was that they fought every Sunday afternoon, on purpose. Marian called it the weekly air-out. They would sit on the porch with coffee and each person would name one thing the other had done that week that had bothered them. The rule was that you had to name it small, before it got big. Peter said, if you let it sit for a month, it is no longer about the thing. It is about your whole life. Marian said, and then you cannot talk about it anymore.
Couple four, Lila and Robert, married forty-one years, both lawyers, Washington DC. Their answer was a thing they called the two-week rule. If one of them was upset about something, they had two weeks to bring it up, or they had to drop it forever. No reviving old grievances after that. Robert said this had forced him to either say the hard thing quickly or genuinely let it go. Lila said it had saved them from at least one divorce, around year nineteen, when something had almost been said too late.
I noticed, around the sixth interview, that none of them were telling me about love. They were telling me about systems. The romance, when it appeared, was almost incidental, mentioned in the way you mention a couch you have had for thirty years. They had loved each other, sure. They also had loved other people during the marriage, several of them said, in small ways that had not turned into anything, but that they had had to choose, daily, not to act on. The choosing was not romantic. The choosing was the marriage.
Couple seven, Ines and Harold, married forty-seven years, both still working part-time in a hardware store they owned in Vermont. Their rule was that they took separate vacations once a year. Ines went to her sister's in Florida for ten days. Harold went fishing with his cousin in Michigan. They said this had been the suggestion of a therapist in 1991 and they had not missed a year since. Ines said, I love coming back. Harold said, I love the third day she is gone, and I love the third day she is back.
Couple eleven was the one that stayed with me. Beatrice and Owen, married forty-four years, both retired professors in Chicago. I asked them my question. Beatrice paused. She said, honestly, we almost did not stay. There was a stretch in our late forties where we were two roommates raising children, and we had a serious conversation about ending it. I asked what changed. She said, we started having dinner alone together once a week. No kids, no friends, no television. Just dinner. At a small Italian place down the street. We did it for two years before it started working. Owen said, the first year was awful. We had nothing to say. We had to learn each other again from scratch.
I asked all twelve couples, at the end, what they would tell my parents. Almost all of them said some version of the same thing. They said, the people who stay together are not the ones who love harder. They are the ones who built the small structures early, the rules about the pots and the bathrooms and the Sundays, that held them up when the love got thin. Love gets thin in every long marriage, they said, at least three or four times. The structures are what carry you across.
I called my mother after the last interview. I did not try to talk her out of anything. I told her what Beatrice had said about the Italian place. She was quiet for a long time. She said, we never did that. We never sat down and just had dinner. I said, I know, Mom. She said, I wish someone had told us about the pots.
About the writer
Naomi Reeve writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.
Also in Relationships
Keep reading
Relationships
I Have Been Calling My Sister Every Tuesday for a Year. We Are Closer Than We Were as Kids.
Naomi Reeve · 7 min read
Relationships
How My Husband and I Repair After a Fight. We Borrowed It From a Podcast and It Works.
Sarah Whitfield · 6 min read
Relationships
My Six-Year-Old Asked If I Was Okay. I Lied. I Have Been Thinking About It Ever Since.
Daniel Ortega · 7 min read