My Six-Year-Old Asked If I Was Okay. I Lied. I Have Been Thinking About It Ever Since.
A small moment at the breakfast table, a sentence I have replayed for three weeks, and the question of what we owe our children when we are not fine.
It was a Tuesday in late April. I was making toast. My daughter Mira, who is six and a half and has a frightening level of emotional radar, was eating a banana at the counter and watching me. She said, Papa, are you okay. I said, of course, mija, I am fine. She nodded and went back to her banana. I burned the toast. I have been thinking about that exchange for three weeks.
The reason I lied was simple and almost reasonable. I had been up since four am because I had been let go from a freelance contract the day before, and I had not yet told my wife, and I was trying to figure out how to tell my wife, and I did not want my six-year-old to absorb any of that at seven fifteen on a Tuesday before school. I made a parenting judgment in the moment. The judgment was, protect the kid. I have made versions of this judgment a hundred times.
But the thing I cannot stop thinking about is that she asked. She asked because she could see it. Whatever I was doing with my face or my shoulders or the way I was buttering toast, it had been visible enough that a six-year-old, mid-banana, had decided to check in on me. And my answer had been a lie. A small, parental, well-intentioned lie. But she had asked a real question and I had given her a fake answer, and I am not sure what I had taught her in that moment.
I called my mother about it that weekend, because my mother is the wisest person I know about this kind of thing, having raised four children mostly alone. She was quiet for a while. Then she said, mijo, I lied to you constantly when you were small. I had to. You cannot tell a five-year-old that you are worried about rent. But she said, the trick I learned, around the time you were eight, was to stop saying I am fine, and to start saying, I am a little tired today, but I am okay, and I love you. She said, that way you are not lying, but you are not asking them to carry it.
I tried this the next time Mira asked, which was about four days later, because she asks me this question more often than I had previously noticed. I said, I am a little tired today, mija, but I am okay. She looked at me carefully. She said, okay, Papa. Then she said, do you want to draw with me. We drew for about eleven minutes. I felt, by the end, less tired. I am not sure if this was the drawing or the not-lying.
I have been reading about this since. There is a body of research, mostly out of the Center on the Developing Child at Harvard, suggesting that children do not need parents who are always fine. They need parents who can name and regulate their own emotions in front of them. Kids who grow up watching adults pretend everything is fine grow up believing they should also pretend everything is fine. Then they become adults who cannot say I am tired without first apologizing for it. I recognized myself in this paragraph immediately.
My father, who I love, was a man who never once told me he was anything other than fine. He died at sixty-four of a heart attack on a Sunday morning in 2014. I do not think the heart attack was directly caused by the fineness. But I think there was a man inside my father I never met, because he had decided, when I was small, that I should not have to meet him. I have spent a lot of my adult life trying to find him in old photographs. I do not want Mira to do this with me.
So I have been experimenting, in small ways, with telling her something closer to the truth. Not the whole truth. She is six. She does not need to know about the freelance contract. But I have stopped saying I am fine. I have started saying, I am a little sad today, but it is not about you, and I love you. Or, I am thinking about something hard, but I will figure it out. She seems to handle this fine. Better than fine. She has started doing it back. Last week she said, Papa, I am a little sad today because Eloise was mean at recess. I said, tell me more. She did.
I am not going to claim that one lie about toast has reorganized my entire approach to parenting. But it has done something. It has made me notice how often I default to fine. With Mira. With my wife. With my mother. With my friends. Fine is the smallest possible answer. It is the answer that closes a door. I am trying, now, in small Tuesday-morning ways, to leave the door open a crack. Mira asked again yesterday. I told her the truth. She drew me a picture of a dog. I have it on the fridge.
About the writer
Daniel Ortega writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.
Also in Relationships
Keep reading
Relationships
I Have Been Calling My Sister Every Tuesday for a Year. We Are Closer Than We Were as Kids.
Naomi Reeve · 7 min read
Relationships
How My Husband and I Repair After a Fight. We Borrowed It From a Podcast and It Works.
Sarah Whitfield · 6 min read
Relationships
The Fight We Have Every Three Months About the Calendar. We Have Made Peace With It.
Margaret Hollis · 6 min read