How My Husband and I Repair After a Fight. We Borrowed It From a Podcast and It Works.
A two-sentence script, used at the end of an argument, has changed our marriage more than any of the couples therapy we have paid for.
My husband Theo and I fight about twice a month. Not big fights. Medium fights. The kind where someone slams a cabinet and someone else takes the dog for a longer walk than usual. We have been doing this for twelve years. For the first ten, our fights ended ambiguously. Someone would eventually say, are we okay, and the other person would shrug, and we would go to bed, and the next morning we would be fine, sort of. The fights never really got resolved. They got absorbed.
Around year ten, I listened to an episode of a podcast called Where Should We Begin, which is Esther Perel doing single-session couples therapy with real couples. The episode was about repair. Perel said something I wrote down. She said, in healthy long-term couples, the fight is not the problem. The lack of repair after the fight is the problem. She said most couples never actually close the loop. They just let it dissolve and assume the next fight will not carry forward the residue of the last one. She said this assumption was always wrong.
She offered, almost in passing, a two-sentence script. Sentence one. Here is what I think I did that hurt you. Sentence two. Here is what I am going to try to do differently. The repairing partner says both sentences. The other partner does not have to say anything. They can just nod. The script is not about who was right. It is about acknowledging the harm and naming an intention. Perel said it should take about ninety seconds. She said most couples never give it ninety seconds.
I brought it to Theo on a Saturday morning, sheepishly, the way you bring home a piece of furniture from IKEA you are not sure your spouse will like. He read the script. He said, okay, we can try it. The next fight was about two weeks later. It was about whether I had been short with his mother at brunch. I had been short with his mother at brunch. The fight lasted about an hour. Then we went to separate rooms, the way we always do.
Forty minutes later, Theo came into the kitchen, where I was angrily reorganizing the spice drawer. He said, okay, here is what I think I did that hurt you. He said it slowly. He said he had not defended me in real time at brunch when his mother had made the comment about my work, and that he had then accused me of being short, which was true but was not the whole story. He said, here is what I am going to try to do differently. He said he would try to say something in the moment next time, even if it was awkward, so that I did not have to absorb it alone.
I did not know what to do. I was holding a jar of cumin. I had been prepared to be angry for at least three more hours. I had a whole plan. I put the cumin down. I said, okay. I said, thank you. We did not talk about it again that day. But something had shifted, structurally, in a way that the previous decade of ambiguous let-it-dissolve repairs had never managed. The fight had a door on it now. The door had been closed.
We have been using the script for about two years. It is not magic. It is awkward, every single time. Theo always sounds slightly like he is reading from a teleprompter when he does it, and I am sure I do too. But we have stopped carrying forward residue. The fights do not stack anymore. The thing about brunch did not show up in the fight about the dishwasher two weeks later, which is what would have happened in the old regime. It got closed off and put away.
The other surprising thing is that the script has changed how we fight, not just how we repair. Because we both know we will have to do the script at the end, we have both gotten slightly more careful in the middle. You do not want to have to apologize for something egregious ninety minutes from now. So you pull a small punch. You do not say the meanest thing. You leave yourself something to come back from. This is, I think, what the seventy-year-old couples meant when they talked about building structures. The script is a small structure. It holds the fight in a shape that it can recover from.
About the writer
Sarah Whitfield writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.
Also in Relationships
Keep reading
Relationships
I Have Been Calling My Sister Every Tuesday for a Year. We Are Closer Than We Were as Kids.
Naomi Reeve · 7 min read
Relationships
My Six-Year-Old Asked If I Was Okay. I Lied. I Have Been Thinking About It Ever Since.
Daniel Ortega · 7 min read
Relationships
The Fight We Have Every Three Months About the Calendar. We Have Made Peace With It.
Margaret Hollis · 6 min read