I Started Saying 'Tell Me More' Instead of 'How Was Your Day.' The Shift Was Real.
Three words, deployed at the right moment, retired the worst question in our marriage.
How was your day is the question equivalent of a dead handshake. I had been asking my wife Priya this question for nine years, usually in the kitchen, usually while one of us was unpacking a Trader Joe's bag, and she had been answering me the same way every single time. Fine. Then she would ask me. I would also say fine. Then we would eat dinner and watch one and a half episodes of something neither of us cared about and go to bed. This was, I now understand, an entire decade of not actually talking.
I read a small line in a Esther Perel newsletter in March that suggested swapping the question for an invitation. Instead of how was your day, try tell me more. The thing about tell me more is that it does not have a yes or no answer, and it does not have a fine answer. It is a door, not a checkbox. It is also, the newsletter pointed out, a question you can only ask if you have first noticed something worth following up on. So you have to listen for at least three seconds before you say it.
The first night I tried, Priya had mentioned, in passing, that a coworker named Brendan had said something weird in a meeting. Old me would have said, oh, fine, and moved on. New me said, tell me more about Brendan. She blinked. She put down the pepper grinder. She told me a fourteen-minute story about office politics that I had had no idea was happening. At minute eleven, she said, I cannot believe I am telling you about Brendan. I said, I cannot believe I have never asked.
The thing nobody warns you about when you do this is that it goes both ways. The next night, I mentioned I had had a strange interaction with my brother on the phone. She said, tell me more. I had not actually planned to talk about my brother. I had planned to mention it and move on because that is what I do with hard things. But she was looking at me, and her hands were still, and the word more was sitting between us like a small open hand. So I talked about my brother for twenty minutes. I had not done that in maybe four years.
Here is what I noticed after about three weeks of this. We started having longer dinners. Not dramatically longer, but maybe eleven minutes longer on average, which is a lot when you count it over a month. We stopped eating in front of a screen because the screen kept interrupting the more. We started telling each other smaller things, things that would not have qualified as worth mentioning under the old regime. The cashier at the wine store remembered her name. My coworker's dog died. The cherry blossoms on Fifteenth Street were starting.
I do not want to make this sound like a productivity hack. It is not a hack. It is more that there had been a kind of crust over our conversations, and tell me more was a small spoon. I am surprised by how much was under there. Priya had been holding back, I think, because she had inferred from years of fine that I was not actually interested. I had been holding back for the same reason. We had taught each other to be boring on purpose.
The real test came on a bad night. She had had a fight with her mother, and she came home with her shoulders up around her ears. Old me would have said, oh no, what happened, in a way that was secretly performative, hoping for a short answer. New me said, tell me more, and then did not say anything else for a long time. She cried a little. She told me the whole thing, including the parts she had not told her sister, including a thing her mother said in 2009 that she had never told anyone. I did not fix any of it. I did not need to. She said later that night, you have gotten better at this. I said, I learned a trick. She said, do not call it a trick.
About the writer
Daniel Ortega writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.
Also in Relationships
Keep reading
Relationships
I Have Been Calling My Sister Every Tuesday for a Year. We Are Closer Than We Were as Kids.
Naomi Reeve · 7 min read
Relationships
How My Husband and I Repair After a Fight. We Borrowed It From a Podcast and It Works.
Sarah Whitfield · 6 min read
Relationships
My Six-Year-Old Asked If I Was Okay. I Lied. I Have Been Thinking About It Ever Since.
Daniel Ortega · 7 min read