Sunday Edition

Plain Sunday

Quietly good ideas for the rest of your week.

The Habits Department

Why I Stopped Trying to Wake Up at 5am — And Got More Done

I gave the 5am Club two months. Then I tried something the productivity books do not tell you, which is to ask when I actually think well.

By Naomi Reeve·Saturday, May 2, 2026·7 min read

I read Robin Sharma's book on a plane in 2024. I bought a sunrise alarm clock. I told my husband, in the slightly evangelical tone I reserve for new systems, that this was the one. For sixty-one days I woke up at 5:04am. I journaled for twenty minutes. I did a workout from the Peloton app, usually a 20-minute walk on the treadmill because that was all I could manage. I drank a green drink that my friend Priya makes with celery and ginger and the will to live.

I lost four pounds. I also lost the entire month of March, in the sense that I cannot recall a single specific thing that happened during it. I was a shell. I worked from a kind of bright-eyed fog. My colleagues told me I seemed 'focused' which I now understand is a polite word for 'unreachable'.

Around day fifty I noticed something that I did not want to notice. My best work, the work I was actually proud of, the strategy decks and the long memos and the difficult emails to the head of marketing, was not happening in the morning. It was happening between 4pm and 7pm. It always had been. I had spent twenty years of my career producing my best output in the late afternoon and trying to retrain myself into a morning person on the side, like a hobby.

So I quit. I started sleeping until 7:15. I moved my hard work to a protected block from 4pm to 6:30pm. I told my team I was unavailable in that window, the same way I would be unavailable for a doctor's appointment. I put it on my calendar in dark red. I called it Deep Work, which is borrowed from Cal Newport and a little embarrassing but effective, because nobody books over something that looks like a meeting.

Three things happened. First, my actual output went up. I shipped two strategy documents in the first month that had been sitting at 60 percent done for almost a year. Second, my mornings became gentle. I read the news, I walked the dog, I made an actual breakfast. Third, and this was the unexpected one, I stopped feeling guilty in the evenings. The 5am version of me had spent every evening at low-grade war with herself about whether she had earned the right to watch television. The 7:15 version of me sits down at 8pm and watches Slow Horses with her whole chest.

The lesson I want to extract, and I am wary of lessons, is that the productivity literature has a strong bias toward mornings because mornings are easy to write about. There is light. There is coffee. There is a clear before-and-after. Late afternoon is harder to romanticize. There is no 4pm Club. Nobody is selling a course called The Magic of 5:18pm. But for a lot of us, including I suspect a lot of women in their late thirties with children and meetings and a long midmorning runway of admin, late afternoon is when our heads finally clear.

The caveat I owe you is that I still wake up early on Saturdays, around 6:30, because the house is quiet and I like to read on the couch with the dog. So I am not anti-morning. I am anti-pretending. The honest question, the one I wish someone had asked me before I bought the sunrise alarm clock, is not when do successful people get up. It is when do you, specifically, think the clearest. The answer for me turned out to be embarrassingly inconvenient, which is part of why it took me so long to admit it.

About the writer

Naomi Reeve writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.