The Tiny Decision I Stopped Making Every Day, and What It Gave Back
I read about decision fatigue in 2019 and dismissed it. Then I quietly applied it to one corner of my life and got a small unexpected hour back.
The Obama thing is well-trodden by now. He wore only gray or blue suits, the story goes, because he did not want to spend cognitive energy on what to wear when he had a country to run. I read the New York Times piece about it in 2019 and rolled my eyes. The suggestion that the most powerful man in the world and I had a comparable decision load felt, frankly, insulting.
I want to amend that. Not because I now think I am as busy as a president. But because I have come to believe that decision fatigue, properly understood, is not about the number of decisions. It is about the texture of the small, repeating ones. And the small repeating ones, the ones that have no real stakes but happen every single day, are the ones that quietly drain you.
The decision I stopped making was what to have for lunch. I work from home four days a week. For years, around 12:15, I would stand in front of the fridge with the door open and conduct a small internal negotiation. Eggs again. Leftovers from last night, but the salmon would be sad. The sandwich, but bread. A bowl of cereal, but it is 12:15. I would end up eating something I did not really want, around 1:10, after losing about forty-five minutes to the back-and-forth.
In February I made a rule. Monday through Thursday, lunch is the same. A bowl of cottage cheese, a sliced tomato with salt, a handful of pistachios, and a piece of whatever fruit is in the bowl. That is it. I eat it at my desk at 12:30. I do not think about it. I do not improve on it. I do not, importantly, feel that I am missing out, because Friday lunch is whatever I want, often something elaborate and slightly indulgent that I look forward to all week.
The amount of time I have gotten back is roughly forty minutes a day, which compounds to about three hours a week, which is approximately a full Saturday morning every month. That is the boring math version. The interesting version is what happened to my afternoons. They are calmer. I am not making my hardest decision of the day at 12:15, which means I am not depleted at 2:30, which means the work I do between 3pm and 5pm is noticeably better. I tracked it. Not scientifically, but well enough.
I have tried to extend this to other domains, with mixed results. Outfits work, but only for weekdays; I want to dress up on Saturdays. Coffee orders work, gloriously; I get a small latte with oat milk every time, I have stopped reading the chalkboard, my barista at the cafe near my office has stopped asking. Workouts do not work; I need variety or I quit. The rule I have settled on is to standardize the decisions I do not enjoy, and protect variety in the ones I do.
The unexpected gift is what I do with the freed-up attention. It is not, as the productivity books promise, that I now use those forty lunch minutes for deep work. I use them to look out the window. I use them to text my sister back. I use them to pet the dog, who is delighted. The reclaimed time has not made me more productive. It has made me more present. Which, on reflection, was what I was actually short on.
The caveat, and there is always a caveat, is that I do get a little tired of cottage cheese around week six. So I rotate. Cottage cheese for six weeks, then a grain bowl for six weeks, then tuna salad for six weeks. The decision I have eliminated is not 'what to eat'. It is 'what to eat today'. The first one is interesting. The second one was killing me.
About the writer
Naomi Reeve writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.
Also in Habits