I Tried Cold Showers for a Month. Here's the Honest Verdict.
The wellness internet promised me focus, mood, immunity, and discipline. I will tell you what I actually got.
I went into this with low expectations and high suspicion. The cold shower discourse online, as far as I can tell, is roughly seventy percent men in their twenties with podcasts and thirty percent people quietly trying it because the men in their twenties with podcasts would not shut up. I am in the second group. I am also a person who, in February, runs her hands under hot water at the sink just to feel something.
The rules. Every shower for thirty days had to end with at least sixty seconds of cold water. Not lukewarm. Cold, the coldest my apartment's plumbing can produce, which in March in my building is roughly the temperature of a glass of iced tea. I could start the shower warm. I could even take a normal hot shower. The cold was the closer.
Days one through four were comedy. I yelped. I bargained. I would get to about fifteen seconds and the part of my brain that runs the body would say, with surprising authority, get out. I would get out. I would tell myself that fifteen seconds counted, which it did not. I would feel like a person who had cheated at the only thing she had set out to do that day.
Around day five, something shifted, and I want to describe it carefully because this is where the cold shower people get oversold. It is not that the cold stopped being cold. It is that I stopped having an opinion about it. The water hit me, I noticed it was cold, I did not editorialize. Sixty seconds passed. I got out. That is the entire skill.
The benefits I noticed, honestly. I felt awake in a way coffee does not produce — sharper, but also calmer, like someone had wiped the lens. This lasted maybe forty-five minutes. My mood in the morning was reliably better, which I cannot fully explain but did not invent. I slept about the same. My skin looked the same. My immune system, as far as I can tell, was the same — I caught a cold in week three like a normal person.
The benefits I did not notice. Discipline. Focus. 'Becoming the kind of person who.' The wellness influencers will tell you that cold exposure rewires your relationship with discomfort, and I am sure for some people it does. For me, it rewired my relationship with the last sixty seconds of my shower. That is it. I did not start waking up at 5 a.m. I did not write a novel. I did not become unflappable in meetings. I just got out of the shower colder.
One thing I will defend. There is a small, useful psychological move in choosing to do something mildly unpleasant first thing in the morning and then discovering you are fine. It is not transformative. It is a tiny rehearsal of the idea that you can decide to do a hard thing and then the hard thing ends. I think that is worth something, even if it is much smaller than the YouTube thumbnails suggest.
Am I still doing it? Mostly. Maybe four mornings a week. I have stopped counting. On the days I skip it, I do not feel worse. On the days I do it, I feel slightly better, in the way a stretched-out muscle feels slightly better. If you are considering it, I would say try it for two weeks, not thirty days, and ignore anyone who tells you it will change your life. It will not. It will make your shower colder. Sometimes that is enough.
About the writer
Naomi Reeve writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.
Also in Wellness
Keep reading
Wellness
The Mental Health Day I Take Every Six Weeks. It's on the Calendar Like a Meeting.
Naomi Reeve · 7 min read
Wellness
The Anti-Supplement Essay I Needed Five Years Ago
Sarah Whitfield · 8 min read
Wellness
I Stopped Drinking on Weeknights for Two Months. Here's What Actually Changed.
Daniel Ortega · 7 min read