Sunday Edition

Plain Sunday

Quietly good ideas for the rest of your week.

The Wellness Department

The Anti-Supplement Essay I Needed Five Years Ago

I spent about $2,400 on supplements between 2021 and 2024. Here is what I learned, and what I now actually take. (It's two things.)

By Sarah Whitfield·Sunday, May 17, 2026·8 min read

At one point in 2023 I had seventeen bottles on my kitchen counter. Magnesium glycinate. L-theanine. Ashwagandha. A multivitamin from a brand that sponsored a podcast I liked. Fish oil. A 'women's hormone support' complex that I am too embarrassed to name. A jar of green powder that cost $68 and tasted like a lawn. I was, by every external measure, taking care of myself.

I was also, internally, exactly as tired and anxious as I had been before I started.

I want to be careful here. I am not a doctor and I am not going to tell anyone what to put in their body. People with real deficiencies — iron, B12, vitamin D in certain climates, things a blood test actually found — should obviously do what their actual doctor says. This is not about them. This is about the much larger group, which includes the person I was three years ago, who is taking supplements because the internet told her she had 'adrenal fatigue' and the bottle was forty dollars and seemed like an answer.

The first thing I noticed, when I started paying attention, is that the wellness supplement industry runs on an extremely clever sleight of hand. It identifies a feeling — tired, foggy, bloated, anxious, 'off' — and then sells you a pill for a deficiency you have not actually been tested for. The feeling is real. The deficiency is hypothetical. The pill is forty dollars. You take it, you feel slightly better for a week because you are paying attention to yourself, and then you feel the same as before, at which point a new pill is advertised to you.

The second thing I noticed is that I could not, if you asked me, tell you what any of the supplements were actually doing. I had not done before-and-after blood work. I had not tracked symptoms with any rigor. I was operating on vibes and ad copy. When I tried, gently, to stop taking them one at a time, I did not feel worse. I felt the same. Seventeen bottles. The same.

The third thing, which took me longer to admit, is that the supplements were a way of feeling like I was doing something about being tired without actually doing the things that would help. The things that would help, for me, were: sleeping more, drinking less, walking after dinner, getting outside in the morning, not working until 10 p.m. The supplements were a tax I was paying so I did not have to do those things. They were also, conveniently, much faster than those things.

I want to talk about cost, because the wellness industry is very good at not talking about cost. I added it up. Across roughly three years, I had spent about $2,400 on supplements. That is a vacation. That is six months of a gym membership at the nice gym. That is a lot of therapy sessions. I had been, in effect, paying $800 a year to feel like I was taking care of myself, while not particularly taking care of myself.

What I take now, in case it is useful. Vitamin D in the winter, because I live somewhere gray and a blood test said I should. A magnesium supplement at night because it seems to help me fall asleep and is cheap, though I will be the first to admit I cannot rule out placebo. That is it. The seventeen bottles are gone. The counter looks weirdly empty. The green powder, in particular, I do not miss.

I am not anti-supplement. I am anti-the-current-supplement-discourse, which has turned ordinary tiredness into a marketing opportunity and convinced a generation of women, especially, that the reason they feel bad is a chemistry problem they can solve with a subscription. Sometimes it is a chemistry problem. Most of the time, in my experience, it is a sleep problem, a stress problem, a schedule problem, or a not-enough-sunlight problem. None of those problems have a Shopify checkout.

If you are reading this with a cabinet that looks like mine used to, I am not telling you to throw it all out. I am telling you to ask, for each bottle, a small honest question. Did a test say I needed this, or did an ad? The answers will sort themselves.

About the writer

Sarah Whitfield writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.