I Tracked Every Time I Opened Instagram for Two Weeks. The Number Was Not the Worst Part.
I expected to feel ashamed of the count. What I actually felt was something stranger, and harder to fix.
I used the Screen Time feature on my iPhone, plus a small paper notebook I kept in my back pocket, the kind with the elastic band. Every time I opened Instagram I made a tally mark. I did not try to change my behavior. I just counted. My therapist suggested it, with the tone of voice she uses when she already knows what I will find.
Day one: 47 opens. Day two: 52. Day three I was at the dentist and I hit 61 before dinner. By the end of the first week the average was 49 opens per day, which works out to once every nineteen minutes of waking life, which means I was, in some real sense, not actually present for nineteen-minute stretches of my own existence.
But the number wasn't the worst part. The worst part was the shape of when I opened it. I opened it in the elevator. I opened it walking from the kitchen to the living room with a glass of water in my other hand. I opened it sitting on the toilet, opened it again washing my hands, opened it a third time while drying them. I opened it during the four-second pause when a webpage was loading. I opened it while my wife was telling me about her sister.
I had told myself, for years, that I used Instagram in small intentional doses. Twenty minutes in the morning with coffee, maybe ten at lunch. That was the story. The notebook said the story was a lie. The phone was a reflex, like scratching an itch I had stopped noticing.
Here is what I tried, and what worked, in order of how much I hated each one. First I moved the app to the last screen, in a folder called Utilities. That lasted one day. My thumb already knew the path; it found the app in nine seconds. Second I turned the icon grayscale using the accessibility shortcut. That lasted four days, and helpfully my opens dropped to 31 a day, but I started using Reddit more, which felt like quitting cigarettes by starting cigars.
The thing that actually worked was almost silly. I put a rubber band around my phone. A plain brown one, the kind that comes around broccoli. To open the phone I had to physically move the band. It introduced a single second of friction and an unmistakable physical signal: you are about to do the thing. My opens dropped to 14 a day in the second week. I did not feel deprived. I felt like someone had turned down a noise I hadn't realized was on.
What I want to say carefully is this. I am not anti-phone. I met two of my closest friends through Instagram. I run a small side business that lives on it. The problem was never the app. The problem was that I had outsourced the management of any unstructured moment to a slot machine, and the slot machine was, on balance, worse at it than I would have been.
The honest caveat is that I cannot tell you my opens stayed at 14. They drifted back up. They are at about 22 now, six weeks in, and I have made my peace with that. The rubber band still lives on my phone. I sometimes catch myself moving it without thinking, which is funny, because that is exactly the behavior I was trying to interrupt. But 22 is not 49, and the elevator rides are quiet again, and last weekend I noticed that my wife's sister got a dog.
About the writer
Daniel Ortega writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.
Also in Habits