Sunday Edition

Plain Sunday

Quietly good ideas for the rest of your week.

The Wellness Department

I Stopped Drinking Caffeine After 11 a.m. for 30 Days. Sleep Was the Smallest Change.

I expected to sleep better. I did, a little. The bigger surprise was the 3 p.m. hour I got back, the one I didn't know I was losing.

By Daniel Ortega·Wednesday, April 22, 2026·7 min read

I drink a lot of coffee. I want to say that up front, because the people writing about caffeine on the internet are usually either evangelists or in recovery, and I am neither. I am a person who orders a large cold brew at 8 a.m. and then, around 2 p.m., orders another one, and then, around 4 p.m., wonders why my chest feels like a hummingbird.

The rule for the experiment was simple. Nothing with caffeine after 11 a.m. Not coffee, not iced tea at lunch, not the Diet Coke I sometimes get from the vending machine when I am trying to power through a deck. Decaf was allowed. Water was allowed. A single morning coffee — I went with a 12 oz pour-over from the place near my office — was allowed and frankly required.

The first three days were unpleasant in a quiet, low-grade way. Not a headache exactly. More like the lighting in my brain got dimmer around 1:30 p.m. I had read that this was the adenosine catching up, the neurochemical your morning coffee blocks from telling your brain it is tired. I did not love the science. I loved less the feeling of staring at a spreadsheet and forgetting what column B was for.

By day five, something interesting happened. The afternoon dip got shorter. It was still there, but instead of lasting three hours it lasted maybe forty minutes. And on the other side of it, I had what I can only describe as a normal afternoon. Not a wired afternoon. Not a crashing afternoon. A flat, usable afternoon. I had forgotten this was an option.

Sleep changed, but less than I expected. I was already a decent sleeper. My Oura ring — yes, I have one, no, I do not trust it completely — said my average sleep score went from a 78 to an 84. My time to fall asleep went from around twenty-two minutes to around fourteen. Real, but not dramatic. If you had told me the only payoff would be eight extra minutes of sleep onset, I probably would not have bothered.

The bigger payoff was the 3 p.m. hour. I did not realize I had been spending it managing my own caffeine. The second coffee, the snack to go with the second coffee, the bathroom trip, the brief jittery overconfidence, the email I would later regret sending. All of that, gone. In its place, a slightly boring but completely functional hour where I just did the work.

Some practical notes. I switched my afternoon ritual to a mug of hot water with lemon, which sounds like something a wellness columnist would say and which I resisted for two weeks before admitting it works. I bought a tin of decaf Earl Grey from Bellocq. On days I really needed a lift, I went for a walk around the block, which is humiliating to admit because every productivity book has said this for forty years and I refused to believe them.

Things I missed. The ritual, mostly. There is something about ordering a coffee at 3 p.m. that feels like permission to take a break. Decaf does not scratch the itch the same way. I also missed the social aspect — when a coworker says coffee, they do not mean herbal tea, and saying actually I'm off afternoon caffeine makes you sound exactly as insufferable as you fear.

I am writing this thirty-six days in. I have not gone back. Not because I made a vow. Because the math, for me, worked out. One coffee in the morning, real sleep at night, a normal afternoon. I do not think this would work for everyone. I think shift workers, parents of small children, and people who genuinely love three coffees a day should ignore me entirely. But if you have been wondering whether the second cup is costing you something — for me, it turned out it was. It was costing me the afternoon.

About the writer

Daniel Ortega writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.