Why My Kitchen Stays Cleaner Since I Stopped Buying Paper Towels
I switched to a stack of cotton bar mops eight months ago. The strange part is what it did to the rest of my counters.
For most of my adult life, a roll of Bounty lived under my sink the way salt lives next to a stove. I went through about one roll a week, sometimes more if I'd cooked anything with oil. I never thought of it as a habit. It was just the thing you have, like a sponge or a dish brush.
Last September, I ran out on a Tuesday night and didn't feel like walking to the bodega. I had a stack of cotton bar mops a friend had given me when I moved in, still in the plastic sleeve. I pulled two out, ran one under the tap, and wiped down the stove. Then I used the dry one to buff the burner grates. It took maybe forty seconds. I went to bed without thinking about it.
I have not bought paper towels since. This was not a planned experiment. It became one only after about three weeks, when I noticed my counters were staying cleaner between deep cleans. Not a little cleaner. Visibly cleaner.
Here is my theory, after eight months. A paper towel is a single-use object, so you reach for it only when something has already gone wrong — a spill, a splatter, grease on the backsplash. A cotton cloth lives on the counter. It is already wet, or already folded next to the sink, and so I wipe things before they become a problem. I wipe the stove after I scramble eggs. I wipe the rim of the olive oil bottle. I wipe the handle of the fridge when I notice a thumbprint. None of these are decisions. They are just the cloth being there.
I keep twelve bar mops in rotation. I bought a twelve-pack of Utopia Towels on Amazon for about fourteen dollars, which is roughly what I used to spend on paper towels in a month. They live in a small wicker basket on the counter, folded into quarters. Dirty ones go in a mesh bag under the sink and I wash them with my kitchen towels on hot, once a week. I have never once run out.
The thing nobody tells you about paper towels is that they are also a small, constant source of visual clutter. The roll sits on a holder, or worse, on the counter, and it is always slightly unspooling. The packaging from the next bulk pack sits in a corner of the pantry. There is a small mental tax to noticing, every few days, that you are running low. All of that is gone now. I did not realize how loud it was until it stopped.
I want to be honest about the catch, because there is one. You do have to do laundry. If you are someone who lets the hamper become a project, this will not work. I started doing a small load of kitchen linens every Sunday morning while I make coffee, and that has been fine, but it is a real load of laundry that did not exist before. I am paying in time and water instead of in paper.
The other thing is raw chicken. I still keep a small roll of paper towels in the back of a cabinet for the specific job of patting dry chicken thighs and wiping the cutting board before it goes into hot soapy water. Maybe one roll every four months. I am not a purist. I just stopped being a customer.
About the writer
Margaret Hollis writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.