Sunday Edition

Plain Sunday

Quietly good ideas for the rest of your week.

The Money Department

Why I Cancelled My 'Free' Premium Card and Use a Debit Card Like an Adult.

The card was technically free if you used the credits. I am tired of the credits. Here is what changed when I went back to a debit card.

By Daniel Ortega·Saturday, May 9, 2026·6 min read

The card was an Amex Gold. The annual fee was $325. The math, as the points blogs love to remind you, was that if I used the $120 in dining credits, the $120 in Uber Cash, the $100 in resort credits, and earned 4x on groceries, I would come out ahead. I did this math, in a spreadsheet, in 2023, and I was correct. I came out ahead by about $180 a year.

I cancelled the card last month. Not because the math stopped working — it still worked, on paper — but because I had become, over three years, a person who organized small parts of my life around credits. I bought GrubHub when I would rather have walked to the Vietnamese place across the street because the $10 monthly credit only worked on GrubHub. I took Ubers I did not need to take in the last week of the month so the $15 in Uber Cash would not expire. I booked a hotel through Amex Travel that was $40 more than the same hotel on Booking because of the resort credit.

The credits, in other words, were not free money. They were a leash. A short, beige, very expensive leash made of points.

I had a moment of clarity in March, standing in a CVS on Mission Street, buying a $14 packet of Advil because I had a $10 dining credit I had not used and the GrubHub minimum was $15 and the cheapest food was a sandwich I did not want. I stood there for a full minute, holding the Advil, and I thought, what am I doing. I went home and called Amex.

The cancellation took twelve minutes. The agent offered me a retention bonus, which I declined. I am not proud of how close I came to taking it. The number was 30,000 points, which is real money. I declined because I had spent the morning realizing that the points were the problem, not the solution.

I went back to the debit card I had used in graduate school. It is from a credit union. It earns no points. It has no credits. It has no minimum spend, no annual fee, no app that gamifies my purchases with a confetti animation when I cross a threshold. When I tap it, money leaves my account. That is the entire feature set. I had forgotten how clarifying that is.

The first month, my spending dropped by about $400, and I cannot fully account for where the $400 went. Some of it was the un-bought Ubers. Some of it was the not-ordered GrubHub. Some of it was, I think, the absence of the small ambient pressure of trying to use the card right, which had been quietly encouraging me to spend more on the things the card rewarded. I had been gamed, gently, for years, and I had not noticed because I was winning the game.

I am not telling anyone to cancel their card. If you fly enough that the points actually become a $1,200 flight to Tokyo, the math is different and you should keep doing what you are doing. I am telling you that if you find yourself, like me, organizing dinners around dining credits, the math is probably no longer working in your favor. The points are working in theirs.

The debit card is, I have to admit, a little boring. It does not feel like winning. It does not give me a little dopamine hit when I check the app. It just shows me what I have and what I have spent, in plain numbers, like a utility. Which is, I have decided, what a card should be. I am thirty-eight years old. I do not need my checking account to feel like a slot machine. I need it to feel like a checking account.

About the writer

Daniel Ortega writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.