What My Grandmother's Grocery List Taught Me About Inflation.
I found her 1987 grocery list in a recipe book. I bought the same items at my local Safeway in 2026. The result was not what I expected.
The list was tucked inside a copy of The Joy of Cooking, written on the back of an envelope from Pacific Bell. It was dated, in her handwriting, March 14, 1987. My grandmother bought, that day in Sacramento: one gallon of whole milk, a dozen large eggs, a five-pound bag of all-purpose flour, a one-pound block of cheddar, a pound of ground beef, a loaf of Wonder bread, two pounds of bananas, a pound of butter, a head of iceberg lettuce, a can of Folgers, and a tube of Crest. The total at the bottom, circled twice: $18.43.
I took the list to Safeway on a Tuesday. I bought, as close to like-for-like as I could manage: a gallon of Lucerne whole milk ($4.79), a dozen large brown eggs ($5.99 — cage-free was the cheapest they had on the shelf), a five-pound bag of Gold Medal flour ($4.49), a one-pound block of Tillamook sharp cheddar ($7.99), a pound of 80/20 ground beef ($7.49), a loaf of Wonder bread ($4.29), two pounds of bananas ($1.38), a pound of Land O'Lakes butter ($6.49), a head of iceberg ($2.99), a 30.5-ounce can of Folgers ($14.99), and a tube of Crest ($4.49). Total: $65.38.
That is 3.55 times what my grandmother paid. If you run it through the official CPI inflation calculator, $18.43 in 1987 should be about $51 today. So my basket was roughly $14 above what pure inflation would predict. I sat in the parking lot with the receipt and did the math twice because I did not believe it the first time.
Where did the extra $14 come from? Two places, mostly. The cheese was the worst offender — a pound of name-brand cheddar has gotten genuinely expensive, and the store brand was sold out, which I now suspect is not an accident. The coffee was the second. My grandmother bought a smaller can; I could only find the 30.5-ounce. The butter was the third. Everything else tracked roughly to inflation, which is to say everything else was bad but not unusually bad.
The thing the exercise taught me, which the news cycle had not, is that inflation is uneven. The bananas are basically the same. The flour is basically the same. The proteins and the dairy have run ahead. If I cooked the way my grandmother cooked — heavier on grains and produce, lighter on meat and cheese — my grocery bill would be closer to what the calculator predicted. The way I had been eating, which is heavier on the expensive corners of the store, was the actual problem.
I did not turn into my grandmother overnight. I did, however, change a few small things. I now buy a brick of store-brand cheese once a week and grate it myself instead of buying the pre-shredded bags, which are 60 percent more per ounce. I switched from Folgers to a bag of whole bean from Trader Joe's that is $7.99 and lasts longer. I buy butter in the four-pound box from Costco when I am there for other reasons. I have started keeping a flour-and-eggs kind of meal in rotation each week — a frittata, a batch of pancakes for dinner, a pot of dumplings — because those are the ingredients that are still, weirdly, a bargain.
My grocery bill in April was $338 for two adults, which is the lowest it has been since I started tracking. I do not credit my grandmother entirely. I credit her envelope-sized math. The thing she knew that I had forgotten is that the receipt is not a record of what things cost. It is a record of what you decided to value that week.
I taped the 1987 list to the inside of a kitchen cabinet. I look at it sometimes when I am about to add a $9 jar of something to the cart. It is not a guilt trip. It is a recalibration. The world is more expensive than it was. It is also full of choices she did not have. The trick, I think, is to know which is which.
About the writer
Margaret Hollis writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.
Also in Money