I Did a No-Spend Month. The Third Week Was the Only One That Mattered.
I tried a no-spend February. The first two weeks were easy and felt smug. The third week was where I learned anything at all.
I had read about no-spend months on a Substack I no longer subscribe to. The rules I set for myself were standard. No discretionary purchases for twenty-eight days. Groceries, bills, gas, and medicine were allowed. No clothes, no books, no eating out, no impulse Targets, no candles, no just one drink, no Etsy, no anything I could plausibly live without. I told my husband. I told two friends. I started on a Sunday.
The first week was a victory lap. I cooked three nights in a row. I made coffee at home. I cancelled brunch with Hannah and felt virtuous about it. I walked past the bookstore on Valencia twice and did not go in. I logged the small wins in a little Field Notes notebook because I am, on some level, a person who likes a chart. The notebook itself, I want to note, I bought in January, which is the only reason it does not count as cheating.
The second week was almost as easy. I had momentum. I had a freezer full of soup. I had told enough people that I felt accountable. I noticed, with mild surprise, that I had not been to a single store other than Safeway. My credit card statement, which I checked on a Friday evening with a kind of nervous pride, was almost blank. I want to be honest: I was a little smug. I thought I had cracked something. I had not.
The third week was when everything started to break. My friend Lila's birthday was on a Thursday. She had picked a restaurant, a Sichuan place on Polk, and there were eight of us going. I could not go. I knew I could not go. I went anyway. I told myself I would order one dish and one tea, and I would Venmo my share exactly. I ordered one dish and one tea. The bill, split evenly because nobody at a birthday wants to math, was $58 a person. I came home and wrote it in the notebook in red pen and felt awful for two days.
What was harder than the $58 was what came after. I had broken the streak, and the part of my brain that had been so well-behaved for two weeks lit up like a slot machine. You already broke it, so. I bought a book on the way home from work on Friday. I bought a candle from the corner store on Saturday because it smelled like cedar and I was tired. I ordered Thai on Sunday because the soup in the freezer had run out and I had not gone grocery shopping. By Wednesday I had spent $210 on the kind of small, dumb things that the first two weeks had been about avoiding.
The third week was the only one that mattered because it was the only one that taught me anything. The first two weeks had taught me that I could white-knuckle a budget for fourteen days, which I already knew. The third week taught me that the real enemy of my budget is not desire. It is shame. The minute I felt like I had failed, I stopped trying. The all-or-nothing mode is the mode that kills me, every time, in every domain — diet, exercise, money, the lot.
I started over on the fourth week, but I changed one rule. I gave myself a fifty-dollar slush for the rest of the month, no questions asked, for the social things I could not predict. I spent thirty-two of it on a coffee with my sister and a small gift for a friend who had a bad week. I came in under on the slush and over on the principle. The total for the month, including the third week disaster, was $312 in discretionary spending. The previous February had been somewhere around $980, although the records get hazy because I had not been tracking.
The lesson, if there is one, is that the budget needs to survive the bad day. A budget that only works when I am being good is not a budget; it is a personality trait, and mine is not reliable. The fifty-dollar slush is, I think, the cheapest insurance policy I have ever bought. I am keeping it. I am also keeping the notebook, which now has, on the inside cover, in slightly dramatic block letters, the words NO ALL-OR-NOTHING, written by me, to me, for next time.
About the writer
Naomi Reeve writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.
Also in Money