Sunday Edition

Plain Sunday

Quietly good ideas for the rest of your week.

The Money Department

I Audited Every Subscription on My Card. The Total Was Worse Than I Thought.

I sat down on a Saturday with a glass of wine and a bank statement and added up every recurring charge. The number was $387 a month. I had guessed $120.

By Sarah Whitfield·Wednesday, April 22, 2026·7 min read

I had guessed $120. The actual number, when I finally sat down with the highlighter and the printed statement and three months of history, was $387. That is $4,644 a year. That is, depending on how you count it, a flight to Lisbon, a used Vespa, or roughly half a year of my Roth IRA contribution.

The audit started because of a charge I did not recognize: $14.99 from something called RTRFresh. I spent twenty minutes Googling before I realized it was Rent the Runway, which I had signed up for in October 2024 for a wedding and never cancelled. I had been paying for fifteen months. That is $224.85 for one borrowed dress.

Here is the full list, more or less in the order I found them, with what I did about each. Netflix, $22.99, kept. Spotify family plan, $16.99, kept but moved to my sister and now I pay $8.50. Hulu with ads, $7.99, cancelled because I have Netflix. Disney+, $13.99, cancelled because I had not opened it since December. Apple One Premier, $37.95, downgraded to Individual at $10.99 because the family plan was sharing with a brother who already pays for his own. Peloton App One, $12.99, cancelled because I have a real gym membership and the math is embarrassing. New York Times, $25, kept because it is the one thing I actually read every day. Washington Post, $12, cancelled with regret. The Atlantic, $7.92, kept. Substack subscriptions, four of them totaling $32, cut to one at $8.

Then the boring ones. iCloud 2TB, $9.99, kept. Google One 2TB, $9.99, cancelled because I was paying for both for no reason. Dropbox Plus, $11.99, cancelled. Adobe Creative Cloud Photography, $9.99, kept because I edit photos. Canva Pro, $14.99, cancelled. Notion, $10, downgraded to free. 1Password Family, $4.99, kept and worth every cent. Headspace, $12.99, cancelled (I have not meditated since 2024 and we both know it). Calm, $14.99, cancelled (same).

Then the ones I had genuinely forgotten existed. A fitness app called FitOn Pro that I signed up for during a free trial in January, $9.99. A meal planning service called PlateJoy, $12.99. A magazine subscription to Bon Appétit in digital form, $5. A photo printing service called Chatbooks that auto-shipped me a book every month for $10 whether I wanted one or not, and I had eleven unopened. A pet insurance policy for a cat who died in 2024 — I am still working through how I missed that one. $32.50 a month for fourteen months after she was gone. That one made me put the highlighter down.

The total cancelled, monthly: $211. The total saved, annually: $2,532. I did not cancel everything. I am not a monk. I kept the things I use weekly and could name what I got from them. I cut the things I had been paying for as a kind of tax on my own optimism — the optimism that I would meditate, that I would meal plan, that I would do an at-home Pilates class at 6 a.m.

What I do now: on the first Saturday of every month, I open the statement, and I read every recurring line. Not the totals. The lines. It takes nine minutes. I have caught two more — a $4.99 weather app I never use and a $19 thing called HBO Max premium that was bundled with something my husband signed up for and forgot. The trick is that the audit is not a one-time event. It is a habit, like flossing, that you will not feel bad about until you skip it for a year.

One more thing. I called Rent the Runway and asked for a partial refund for the months I had clearly not used. They gave me three months back, which was $44.97. It took eleven minutes on hold and one slightly awkward conversation with a very kind person named Devon. The lesson, which I keep relearning, is that the worst they can say is no, and they usually do not.

About the writer

Sarah Whitfield writes for Plain Sunday from a small kitchen table, somewhere with a kettle on.